Reality: Mandatory & Required

For some reason I’ve been thinking about people’s use of the words Mandatory and Required lately. It’s probably because it’s getting closer to tryout season, which reminds me of coaches using these words poorly. I’ve heard several coaches say a tuck is required to be on their team. They print it on their tryout flyers and tell it to everyone that will listen. They then turn around and put people without tucks on the team because they don’t have enough people with tucks to create a team. These coaches knew they wouldn’t have enough people with tucks to choose from, but insisted on saying a tuck is mandatory.

I’ve also heard several coaches say practice is mandatory, but they let people miss over and over again without consequence. I think stating something one way, when reality shows things are different is a poor choice to make. In the scenarios above I wonder how many people don’t tryout because they don’t think they’ll make it without a tuck or had previously scheduled something during a mandatory practice, but in reality are better than some of the people that made it without a tuck or will miss more mandatory days.

I guess I’m trying to say don’t scare people off with all these grand “requirements” that are really just a wish list and aren’t actually required. Work with reality, which is a place in which saying something is mandatory doesn’t make it automatically happen.

Does Reality Matter?

My question is how much does reality matter? I ask on a few levels, but first let me tell a story. A few years ago I took a trip to NY with a few friends, 8 of us in total. One night 4 of us, 2 guys and 2 girls, sat in my room and talked over a few drinks. We all wound up sleeping in the 2 beds in my room. When I got back home my girlfreind was insisting I had hooked up with the person I slept next to. (How she found out about it prior to me making it home is a story for another day). It was the beginning of the continuous fight that became our end. This is one example of the reality of me not cheating on my girl didn’t matter because she beleived I did.

Another example is clinical drug trials. There are often instances where the group taking the placebo reports having their condition improve in the same manner as the group taking the experimental drug. Their belief in the drug enabled them to improve when the reality was the drug didn’t do anything for them. In other words, reality did not matter. Some aspects of dreams come to mind. I’ve had many dreams that were so realistic they influenced my actions in the real world. How many other scenarios does this apply to?